This is the first in an occasional series of great graveside movie scenes.
What’s Eating Gilbert Grape (1993) is my favorite movie. The perfection of the film needs to be the subject of another (long!) blog post. Of course, you can’t have a great movie without a good book on which it’s based, the 1991 novel by Peter Hedges. This is a rare example of where the movie is as good (may I say, even better?) than the book.
The movie stars Johnny Depp, Leonardo DiCaprio, and John C. Reilly before they became huge break-out stars, back when they were starring in thoughtful, indie movies rather than in pandering-to-the-masses blockbusters.
This scene takes place at the graveside service of Ken Carver, the small town’s insurance agent. All of the main characters are there: Gilbert (Depp), the young man who feels trapped by the small town because he’s the head of his family and has to take care of his severely obese mom and developmentally disabled brother, Arnie (DiCaprio); Tucker (Reilly), one of Gilbert’s buddies; and Mary Steenburgen, starring as Betty Carver.
What is a graveside movie scene without something going terribly awry? A graveside service is the perfect moment to insert tension, drama, conflict. Otherwise it wouldn’t be worth mentioning in a book or movie, right?
My favorite part of this scene is the look on Tucker’s face when he realizes the Burger Barn is finally coming to town. Prior to this scene, the Burger Barn is all that Tucker can talk about. The coming of Burger Barn, a fast-food restaurant, is the best thing that’s happened to this dying town in years. It’s the type of event that surely made the front page of the local newspaper, probably for many editions in a row. Tucker has been named manager of the Burger Barn, hence his sense of pride when he sees the building passing by.
Even though the scene takes place at the burial of Ken Carver, we also get a metaphorical sense that the town is dying, and that Gilbert, too, is dying a little inside, trapped in a situation from which he thinks he cannot escape. Will he be working at the tiny grocery store for the rest of his life? Will he ever get out? Will he ever be able to pursue his dreams or is he destined to always be the family’s caretaker? When the fun-loving Becky (Juliette Lewis) comes to town, we get a chance to find out.
Have you seen or read Gilbert Grape? What do you think? What’s your favorite movie graveside scene, and why? I have others in mind that I’ll be posting in the future.